Zizania latifolia at Patching
Source: Hollings, Mike, and Olwen Hollings. “Zizania latifolia at Patching.” Sussex Botanical Recording Society Newsletter, no. 51 (Jan 2001). http://sussexflora.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/Newsletter_Jan_2001.pdf.
The Hollings were intrigued by articles on this rare alien in BSBI News 84 and, for the benefit of SBRS members who do not receive BSBI News, we include a slightly shortened version of their response:
We were reading through the recent articles by Ken Page and by Eric Clement on Manchurian Wild Rice (Zizania latifolia) in southern England when we came to the words: ‘v.c.13 (W.Sussex). Lake margin by main road, Patching, nr Worthing, 1947.H.K.Airy Shaw.’ Instantly, we sat up with a start; ‘that’s Patching Pond for Pete’s sake’, we cried, ‘must be’. Wondrous aliens always turn up on the other fellow’s patch, yet this one is almost on our doorstep. And how right Eric is to say, ‘Look at the leaves’, for Patching Pond has been a classical botanising spot for over half a century, yet none of us since Airy Shaw appears to have ‘seen’ this plant!
Next day (12 April 2000) we were at Patching Pond. The old main road (A27) has now been sidelined by the new dual carriageway, making access and parking beside the pond much easier and quieter, at TQ087055. This is along the southern edge of the pond, and the Wonder Grass is growing just beyond the low wooden fence. All along the southern edge, within c.5m of the shore, were a dozen or more tussocks sticking out of the water, each c.50 cm across by 20 cm high, fairly close to the gentle outflow sluice. Each tussock was a collapsed heap of dry, beige-brown dead leaves from last year, with no sign of any flowering/fruiting stems. The sharply toothed margins still had a vicious edge. Numerous new leaf shoots had already pushed up through the tussocks, and others were projecting 15-25 cm directly from the water. All were of a most striking vivid green colour, markedly different from the young leaves of Typha and Phragmites growing nearby. Several other big areas of Z.latifolia were growing around the edges of the pond.
It proved quite hard to pull out a piece of a plant with roots and rhizomes attached; the latter were extremely tough and had to be cut with a sharp blade. Indeed, a couple of times we nearly did a natty back-somersault into the wet stuff before eventually getting some samples for photography and further study at home. At this stage, the young leaves were in-rolled and had not yet developed the rows of forward-pointing spines along the margins, nor the maroon-red patches at the base of each leaf-sheath. A pair of Mute Swans swam up, plucked about 7 cm from several leaf tips, and ate them with evident relish.
By 24 April, the leaves were 30-40 cm clear of the water, still showed some in-rolling but had now very slight marginal teeth. By 12 May, the plants were 75-90 cm high, most leaf laminae were completely flat with sharp marginal teeth, and maroon patches had appeared at the bases of a few leaf sheaths. The Mute Swans had now definitely lost interest. On 31 May, nearly all the leaves were quite flat and tapering at each end, and the separate tussocks were now being obscured by more continuous foliage. By June 11 all tussocks had vanished in the solid wall of upright culms, the plants were 90-120 cm high, the leaves broad and the maroon leaf sheath patches very conspicuous. A week later, the plants were 145 cm high, still a bright vivid green, and by 17 July were 210 cm tall; the maximum leaf width was still 42mm, and individual leaves were c.125 cm long, tapered at each end. We saw no cross-veins in the leaves we examined.
The chambered rhizomes were up to 22mm diameter tapering to sharply pointed tips, and exceedingly tough. Roots and culms had developed at many nodes, which were very hard, solid and woody in contrast to the papery septa between nodes. Young roots were very white, brittle and up to 1mm diameter with no root hairs. By contrast, older roots were a bright tawny-orange, over 60 cm long with numerous fine root hairs.
After 3 months in plastic tubs 48×48 cm, 25 cm deep, and filled with water and some bottom mud, single culms with a few roots had grown virtually to fill the entire space with a dense tangle of roots and rhizomes. Our experience at Patching Pond suggested Zizania had done the same thing in the mud there. So we began making local enquiries.
For many years, the pond has been leased by the Worthing Piscatorial Society, and their Secretary told us that they had been aware of the ‘giant rush’ for over 40 years. In the 1960’s, the plants occupied a very much smaller area than now, but in recent years have caused increasing problems. Mechanical diggers were brought in to remove the roots and rhizomes from successive stretches of the margins, and in 1999, over 80 tons of Zizania were removed. Yet the plant bounces back, as vigorous as ever!
On the gastronomic front, Joy Larkcom gives helpful comments in ‘Oriental Vegetables’ (1991, John Murray) and points out that, to grow well, Z.latifolia needs high temperatures (20-30°C) and intense light with a slightly acidic clay soil. The plants at Patching Pond seem to manage with what W.Sussex has to offer – is this global warming in our midst? In SE Asia, infection with the fungus Ustilago esculenta is regarded as essential, producing indoleacetic acid which induces the stem to swell to 17 cm long by 3 cm wide, but the plant must be harvested before the fungus starts to produce spores, for the flesh then deteriorates. Cultivated forms are often preferred, for wild genotypes have developed resistance to this smut fungus. Perhaps infection with the smut fungus inhibits the rampant growth and might even explain the dwarfing to 4ft (1.2m) quoted by Eric Clement. Flavour is described as mild, pleasant and reminiscent of celeriac, but it is also widely used in various Chinese dishes to absorb other flavours. However, many fungi produce highly toxic substances, including some of the world’s favourite carcinogens, so it might pay to let the other fellow try the culinary delights first! We have seen no sign so far of any swelling of the stem base or fungal infection.
Rather than any need for help or protection, vigorous control measures would seem to be necessary for Zizania. Perhaps the folk operating the local Chinese Takeaways might be encouraged to harvest it in a big way!
